„Good intentions and inspiration are simply not enough.“

Thank Goodness! (2006)
Contesto: One thing in particular struck me when I compared the medical world on which my life now depended with the religious institutions I have been studying so intensively in recent years. One of the gentler, more supportive themes to be found in every religion (so far as I know) is the idea that what really matters is what is in your heart: if you have good intentions, and are trying to do what (God says) is right, that is all anyone can ask. Not so in medicine! If you are wrong —especially if you should have known better — your good intentions count for almost nothing. And whereas taking a leap of faith and acting without further scrutiny of one's options is often celebrated by religions, it is considered a grave sin in medicine. A doctor whose devout faith in his personal revelations about how to treat aortic aneurysm led him to engage in untested trials with human patients would be severely reprimanded if not driven out of medicine altogether. There are exceptions, of course. A few swashbuckling, risk-taking pioneers are tolerated and (if they prove to be right) eventually honored, but they can exist only as rare exceptions to the ideal of the methodical investigator who scrupulously rules out alternative theories before putting his own into practice. Good intentions and inspiration are simply not enough.In other words, whereas religions may serve a benign purpose by letting many people feel comfortable with the level of morality they themselves can attain, no religion holds its members to the high standards of moral responsibility that the secular world of science and medicine does! And I'm not just talking about the standards 'at the top' — among the surgeons and doctors who make life or death decisions every day. I'm talking about the standards of conscientiousness endorsed by the lab technicians and meal preparers, too. This tradition puts its faith in the unlimited application of reason and empirical inquiry, checking and re-checking, and getting in the habit of asking "What if I'm wrong?" Appeals to faith or membership are never tolerated. Imagine the reception a scientist would get if he tried to suggest that others couldn't replicate his results because they just didn't share the faith of the people in his lab! And, to return to my main point, it is the goodness of this tradition of reason and open inquiry that I thank for my being alive today.

Estratto da Wikiquote. Ultimo aggiornamento 03 Giugno 2021. Storia
Daniel Dennett photo
Daniel Dennett9
filosofo e logico statunitense 1942

Citazioni simili

John Steinbeck photo

„Intention, good or bad, is not enough.“

—  John Steinbeck, libro L'inverno del nostro scontento

Origine: The Winter of Our Discontent

John Steinbeck photo

„… intentions, good or bad, are not enough. There's luck or fate or something else that takes over…“

—  John Steinbeck, libro L'inverno del nostro scontento

Origine: The Winter of Our Discontent

Jim Butcher photo
Larry Ellison photo

„If an open source product gets good enough, we'll simply take it.“

—  Larry Ellison American internet entrepreneur, businessman and philanthropist 1944

Financial Times interview (18 April 2006) http://us.ft.com/ftgateway/superpage.ft?news_id=fto041820061306424713.
Contesto: If an open source product gets good enough, we'll simply take it. So the great thing about open source is nobody owns it – a company like Oracle is free to take it for nothing, include it in our products and charge for support, and that's what we'll do. So it is not disruptive at all – you have to find places to add value. Once open source gets good enough, competing with it would be insane. … We don't have to fight open source, we have to exploit open source.

Ilchi Lee photo
Peter Abelard photo

„In fact we say that an intention is good, that is, right in itself, but that an action does not bear any good in itself but proceeds from a good intention.“
Bonam quippe intentionem, hoc est, rectam in se dicimus, operationem vero non quod boni aliquid in se suscipiat, sed quod ex bona intentione procedat. Unde et ab eodem homine cum in diversis temporibus idem fiat, pro diversitate tamen intentione eius operatio modo bono modo mala dicitur.

—  Peter Abelard French scholastic philosopher, theologian and preeminent logician 1079 - 1142

Ethica, seu Scito Teipsum, Bk. 1; translation by D E Luscombe from Peter Abelard's Ethics (1971) p. 53
Contesto: In fact we say that an intention is good, that is, right in itself, but that an action does not bear any good in itself but proceeds from a good intention. Whence when the same thing is done by the same man at different times, by the diversity of his intention, however, his action is now said to be good, now bad.

Anthony Robbins photo
Samuel Johnson photo

„Hell is paved with good intentions.“

—  Samuel Johnson English writer 1709 - 1784

April 14, 1775
Malone added a footnote indicating this is a "proverbial sentence", quoting an earlier 1651 source. At least two other sources appear prior to Johnson. John Ray, in 1670, cited as a proverb, "Hell is paved with good intentions." Even earlier than that, it has been attributed to Saint Bernard of Clairvaux (1091-1153), as "Hell is full of good intentions or desires."
[alt.quotations, Earlier Attributions, Wilson, Robert, UseNet, 2009-01-06]
Note that "The road to Hell…" is not part of the quotation.
The Samuel Johnson web site suggests this entry is dated 16 April, but it appears to be part of the previous entry.
Samuel Johnson web site http://www.samueljohnson.com/road.html
Life of Samuel Johnson (1791), Vol II
Origine: The Life of Samuel Johnson LL.D. Vol 2

Sam Harris photo
Edward Albee photo

„Dashed hopes and good intentions. Good, better, best, bested.“

—  Edward Albee, Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?

Origine: Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?

Carlos Ruiz Zafón photo

„The road to hell is paved with good intentions.“

—  Carlos Ruiz Zafón, libro Marina

Origine: Marina

Ben Jonson photo
Margaret Fuller photo

„If nature is never bound down, nor the voice of inspiration stifled, that is enough.“

—  Margaret Fuller, libro Woman in the Nineteenth Century

Woman in the Nineteenth Century (1845)
Contesto: Harmony exists no less in difference than in likeness, if only the same key-note govern both parts. Woman the poem, man the poet; woman the heart, man the head; such divisions are only important when they are never to be transcended. If nature is never bound down, nor the voice of inspiration stifled, that is enough.

David Cameron photo

„Of course, this extremist ideology is not true Islam. That cannot be said clearly enough. But it is not good enough to say simply that Islam is a religion of peace and then to deny any connection between the religion of Islam and the extremists. Why? Because these extremists are self-identifying as Muslims.“

—  David Cameron Former Prime Minister of the United Kingdom 1966

On Islamic extremism at 2015 Lord Mayor’s Banquet - "Lord Mayor’s Banquet 2015: Prime Minister’s speech" Gov.uk (16 November 2015) https://www.gov.uk/government/speeches/lord-mayors-banquet-2015-prime-ministers-speech
2010s, 2015

Dejan Stojanovic photo

„Holy books are an insult to a God with good intentions.“

—  Dejan Stojanovic poet, writer, and businessman 1959

“Insult I,” p. 104
The Sun Watches the Sun (1999), Sequence: “Is It Possible to Write a Poem”

N. K. Jemisin photo

„Good intentions are pointless without the will to implement them.“

—  N. K. Jemisin, libro The Broken Kingdoms

Origine: The Broken Kingdoms (2011), Chapter 16 “From the Depths to the Heights” (watercolor) (p. 281)

Jami photo

„Good intentions are useless in the absence of common-sense.“

—  Jami Persian poet 1414 - 1492

An argosy of fables, p. 240
about himself, Extracted from Baharīstān-e- Jami

Henry David Thoreau photo

„Be not simply good; be good for something.“

—  Henry David Thoreau, libro Life Without Principle

Origine: Life Without Principle

George Raymond Richard Martin photo

Argomenti correlati